The Sly Capitalist Seduction Of “Fifty Shades Of Grey”

The Sly Capitalist Seduction Of “Fifty Shades Of Grey”

click photo for more information
The Sly Capitalist Seduction Of “Fifty Shades Of Grey”
Beneath the BDSM trappings of Fifty Shades lies the fantasy that wealth will set us free. Warning: Spoilers! View this image › Universal Pictures The most dramatic reveal of Fifty Shades of Grey isn’t the Red Room of Pain. It’s not Dakota Johnson’s pubic hair, or even Jamie Dornan’s abs. It’s Christian Grey’s penthouse: bathed […]

Beneath the BDSM trappings of Fifty Shades lies the fantasy that wealth will set us free. Warning: Spoilers!

Universal Pictures

The most dramatic reveal of Fifty Shades of Grey isn’t the Red Room of Pain. It’s not Dakota Johnson’s pubic hair, or even Jamie Dornan’s abs. It’s Christian Grey’s penthouse: bathed in 50 shades of West Elm, with a panoramic view of Seattle. The proceeding scenes had functioned as capitalistic foreplay: We see his towering office buildings, with the crisp white and stainless steel that connote very important business going on here.

The women wear tight but super-formal suits with French twists, the actual embodiment of sexy fancy money. Grey’s suits are tightly fitted, and his repeated action of standing up, buttoning his suit jacket, and sitting down at his desk to unbutton is filmic shorthand for seven-figure income. Then there’s the matter of his driver and helicopter: two things that subtract all that’s unglamorous or uncomfortable about getting from one place to another. And more than fancy fabrics or expensive diamonds, that’s what signifies luxury today: freedom from inconvenience.

Grey’s apartment seems a natural extension of that luxury. He steps off the helicopter and directly into his home, where all manner of high-class goods — clothes, food, wine — magically appear. One look at the Focus Features website designed around it, complete with tours of each room, wine and food suggestions, and the opportunity to take a screenshot of the space and share it with your social network, and the actual fetish objects of the film become stunningly transparent.

In this way, the sexual fantasy that undergirds Fifty Shades of Grey is inextricable from the class fantasy: No one would be compelled by the fantasy of a man who gets off on restraining and whipping a woman in trailer park, or even a suburban split-level. The eroticism is rooted in desire, in lack, in curiosity: What would my life be like if I were sexually submissive? is just as a central question as What would my life be like if I never had to worry about money?

Christian even articulates as much. He conceives of control not as punishment, but the ultimate in liberation: to be oneself, to experience pleasure, to revel in the absence of choice.

In his “contract,” Grey outlines all the ways in which Ana must be submit to his demands: He’ll control her health, her drinking, her diet, her method of birth control; how many nights they’ll stay together; when and how she’ll respond to his sexual demands; how she’ll be treated if she disobeys him. We’re meant to understand that Ana doesn’t have taste (she can’t dress herself; she drinks cosmos) or means (she drives an old Volkswagen Beetle; her computer is dead), so someone controlling that taste and offering her means, however circumscribed, is something like freedom — freedom from thinking, from deciding, from choosing: all the things that characterize our exhausting and overstimulated existence within capitalism.

Here, Grey reproduces the rhetoric espoused by cultures past and present in which submission to patriarchy is figured as emancipation from vanity, worry, and self-consciousness. Every woman should be so lucky as to have someone to tell her how to live her life. It’s not difficult to see how this scenario, however seemingly regressive, morphs into fantasy: Sure, you surrender a modicum of free will, but free will is exhausting.

Universal Pictures

And even though we never get the sense that Ana is a gold digger, she’s absolutely awed by Christian’s bounty. When we see the view from the penthouse, or the 360 of “her room,” or even a beautifully poured glass of wine, it’s all shot with the wonder and beguilement as seen through Ana’s eyes. And Ana, like Twilight’s Bella Swan character with whom she shares significant DNA, is a classic cipher: a fairly undeveloped character onto whom female readers of the book can map themselves and, by extension, surrender more fully in the fantasy scenario.

You can feel Ana’s desire and apprehension when Christian first climbs on the bed and eats a bite of her toast; you feel her writhing anticipation as he binds and blindfolds and slips an ice cube down her chest. But you also feel the glee at having a fashionable and expensive outfit waiting for you every morning, and the revelry in a massive, open-design kitchen fully stocked with infinite breakfast items and beautiful kitchenware. And no need to clean up! It’s like a scene straight out of a harried, working mother’s daydream.

Unexpectedly, Fifty Shades, at least in its filmic version, does something fascinating with this fantasy space, examining just how hollow this vision really is once obtained. Christian, after all, is a hollow version of a capitalist: His wealth simply is; his “business” consists of one scene of yelling Get it done in 24 hours! into a phone. Only the appearance of business, no actual labor. And the capitalist fantasy — of the penthouse, of her own room — soon seems shabby, even seedy, once held up to closer scrutiny. It’s almost as if the last third of the film was shot through a different, darker lens as the luxuries reveal themselves, like Grey’s business, to be little more than a front to cover a gaping emotional and psychological abyss beneath.

Ana’s hesitancy to sign the contract — which would render her a component of his financial and emotional enterprise — signals her dubiousness toward the entire scenario. The fancy dresses are nice, and so are those early (assumed) orgasms, but she sees that even a fully furnished room of her designing is still a room in which she must spend her nights alone.

When Ana leaves Christian at film’s end, it’s ostensibly an indictment of his inability to open himself up to love and vulnerability. But she’s also grown disillusioned with the “freedom” of luxury: She returns the glossy MacBook he bought for her and asks him to return her VW, only to learn that it’s been sold. Instead of an actual mode of transportation, however old and clunky, she’ll be left with a barely enough to buy bus fare — literally stranded by her faith in the fantasy of wealth. Ana rejects Christian’s vision of control and subsequent liberation through sex, but she’s also saying fuck you to the theory that a life of luxury will inure a woman to the lack of true companionship, respect, communication.

For Fifty Shades to end as it does, with such a clear rejection of both Christian and the lifestyle he promises, is a radical act. The scene in which Christian whips Ana — and forces her to count along, complicit in her own abuse — is a searing commentary on what women are willing to endure for the promise of love. Ana is essentially rejecting the ideals (hot dudes, perfect body, endless privilege) to which popular culture has taught us to surrender and, in so doing, she explodes them. The hot dude is rotten inside; his version of BDSM isn’t about mutual pleasure, but using his capital to compel women to endure sex that they don’t like so that they can enjoy the lifestyle they do.

Universal Pictures

That’s an uncharitable understanding of any man’s intention, but the text, with its flimsy characterization and hackneyed psychology (childhood abuse yields adult perversion) gives us little reason to believe otherwise. Yet fully drawn character and cohesive plot has never been the point. People didn’t buy this book or see this movie merely because it’s erotica. It can, in a spare number of scenes, genuinely arouse, but what’s really compelling about Fifty Shades is the way in which it negotiates the knife-edge between control and release, freedom and submission, both sexual and financial. BDSM simply becomes the taboo playground on which those larger, enduring, and never more essential ideas are set out.

Like all fantasy, it’s less about actually submitting or dominating and more about thinking about it. We’re not meant to treat Fifty Shades as a how-to book, which is why most (but not all) debates over the way in which it might inculcate domestic abuse lack nuance. Such thinking harkens back to old, thoroughly disabused theories that a film, book, or song is a hypodermic needle that, once injected in its viewer, reproduced its values in its new host. Instead, women — and some men — are watching Fifty Shades and processing how that vision of surrender, and Ana’s ultimate rejection of it, meshes with their own ideas of freedom. That’s how we consume media: We digest it.

The problem, of course, is that the full Fifty Shades narrative doesn’t end with Ana’s rejection. It’s a momentary pause before the pair are reconciled at the beginning of the second movie. Love and communication “fix” Christian’s perversions, leaving the pair to marry, have children, and live out the bourgeois fantasy that soured so effectively at the end of the first movie. Indeed, the biggest spoiler of the Fifty Shades trilogy is that a potential deviant text so thoroughly and unproblematically reifies the status quo. On its own, however, this first Fifty Shades might just be an indictment not only of capitalism, but the exploitative sexual contracts, formal or implicit, that women submit to in its service.











Read more: http://www.buzzfeed.com/annehelenpetersen/submit-to-capitalism

This Crafter Just Took Discarded Floorboards From Trash To Kitchen Treasure

click photo for more information
This Crafter Just Took Discarded Floorboards From Trash To Kitchen Treasure
As a kid, I was always confused when my mom — as moms are wont to do — told me she wanted the floors “so clean you could eat off of them” when it came time to do chores. To my 10-year-old brain, that seemed like a really, really stupid thing to do, since kitchen […]

He Tried To Commit Suicide And Was Left Disfigured. Now He Has A New Lease On Life.

click photo for more information
He Tried To Commit Suicide And Was Left Disfigured. Now He Has A New Lease On Life.
The idea of getting a face transplant is relatively new because our technology has only recently been able to accomplish such a complex task. Dr. Samir Mardini is a doctor who specializes in facial reconstruction and he met Andy Sandness shortly after one of the most difficult days of his life. Sandness was depressed and […]

Animal Rescuers Saw A ‘Sea Of Yellow’ When They Stepped Onto This Terrible Scene

click photo for more information
Animal Rescuers Saw A ‘Sea Of Yellow’ When They Stepped Onto This Terrible Scene
When animal rescuers from the RSPCA stepped onto a field in Cambridgeshire, England, they were shocked to see a “sea of yellow.” Over 1,000 baby chicks had been cruelly abandoned and left to die. Although it’s always heartbreaking to see abandoned dogs and cats, these types of cases are not uncommon. A thousand neglected chicks […]

How We Beat Measles In The ’90s — And Why It Won’t Work Now

click photo for more information
How We Beat Measles In The ’90s — And Why It Won’t Work Now
During the 1989–1991 outbreak, measles was an issue of poverty. Now it’s a personal choice. View this image › Getty Images / Joe Raedle / Via gettyimages.com In response to the current measles outbreak, public health officials and the media have struggled to understand who anti-vaccination parents are. Where do they live? (Orange County.) What […]

The Number Of Reported Child Suicides Has Nearly Doubled — These Are The Signs

click photo for more information
The Number Of Reported Child Suicides Has Nearly Doubled — These Are The Signs
A swarm of children huddled around a petite casket, each holding onto a powder blue balloon and carrying a note to their fellow classmate, Ashlynn Conner. Ashlynn’s older sister discovered the 10-year-old hanging from a clothing rod just a day after coming home in tears and asking to be taken out of school. Her parents […]

The FDA Just Gave 23andMe A Major Victory

click photo for more information
The FDA Just Gave 23andMe A Major Victory
Consumer genetics testing startup 23andMe can now tell people about their risk for one inherited disease. It’s a big first step. View this image › 23andMe CEO Anne Wojcicki speaks at an announcement for the Breakthrough Prize in Life Sciences at Genentech Hall on UCSF’s Mission Bay campus in San Francisco, Wednesday, Feb. 20, 2013. […]

My Boyfriend Loves Fat Women

click photo for more information
My Boyfriend Loves Fat Women
As a fat woman myself, I’m still struggling with how I feel about it. View this image › Jenny Chang / BuzzFeed Ironically enough, I met my boyfriend during the thinnest month of my life. I was at a friend’s birthday party at a bar when I saw my future boyfriend Brian from across the […]

Dad Is Horrified When He Finds Out Where His Ex Is Keeping Their Kids

click photo for more information
Dad Is Horrified When He Finds Out Where His Ex Is Keeping Their Kids
Even when marriages don’t work out, parents can generally trust that their exes will do a decent job taking care of the kids when it’s their turn to spend time with them. Sure, differences of opinion can arise in any co-parenting relationship, but most moms and dads just want their kids to be happy and […]

You’ve Heard Of Ebola, But Here Are Other Dangerous Diseases To Worry About.

click photo for more information
You’ve Heard Of Ebola, But Here Are Other Dangerous Diseases To Worry About.
Ebola continues to spread to different parts of Africa as the world looks on. Every year there seems to be a new disease or health crisis to worry about. But, people forget that there are many diseases out there that may not by as widespread as this recent outbreak, but are no less deadly. (Not […]

People Worldwide Are Honoring A Dying Teen’s Last Wish — You May Want To As Well

click photo for more information
People Worldwide Are Honoring A Dying Teen’s Last Wish — You May Want To As Well
Almost two years ago, now 17-year-old Rebecca Schofield from Riverview, New Brunswick, had a cancerous brain tumor removed. After months of chemotherapy, “All her scans were clear. We thought we were out of the woods,” said her mom, Anne Schofield. But late last year, doctors found two more tumors that were inoperable. They told Rebecca […]

When Children With Autism Grow Up

click photo for more information
When Children With Autism Grow Up
I was 23 and needed a summer job; he was 21 and needed full-time support. He’s one of an estimated half million people diagnosed with autism who are soon becoming adults — and who society is entirely unprepared for. The heat that afternoon was intense. Weather maps across Iowa were deep red, and warnings flashed […]

The Reasons Why You Hate Going To The Gym.

click photo for more information
The Reasons Why You Hate Going To The Gym.
Everyone hates going to the gym. If anyone tells you differently, they are a psychopath. There are plenty of reasons to hate the gym, and no one in the world has time to go through all of them, so we will just explore a few here. It’s Expensive. raquelokyay A good gym in New York […]

Fourteen Shots In April

click photo for more information
Fourteen Shots In April
A new Wisconsin law was supposed to get justice for slain victims of police shootings, like Dontre Hamilton. Here’s what happened. View this image › Chris Ritter / BuzzFeed The second time the two Milwaukee police officers were called to Red Arrow Park about Dontre Hamilton sleeping on the bench, the cops went right up […]

26 Questions That Will Enrage Anyone With Curly Hair

click photo for more information
26 Questions That Will Enrage Anyone With Curly Hair
“Can I touch it?” Sure, if I can touch your face after. IN SLAP FORM. 1. “Ooooh, where’d you get your perm?” View this image › seventeen.com This incredible new salon called THE WOMB, THE DNA POOL, MY GENETIC DISPOSITION. 2. “How do you have sooooo much hair?” View this image › Disney / Via […]

There Is One Thing You Should Be Eating Every Day, And It’s Not What You’d Expect

click photo for more information
There Is One Thing You Should Be Eating Every Day, And It’s Not What You’d Expect
Bananas are delicious, healthy snacks. It’s really a shame that we don’t eat more of them. Sadly, these awesome yellow fruits are still more closely associated with chimps than they are with humans. Well, here are a few reasons why we should take notes from our monkey friends. Bananas are packed with loads of benefits, […]
More