Virtual Reality’s Nagging Problem: It Makes Some People Sick

Virtual Reality’s Nagging Problem: It Makes Some People Sick

click photo for more information
Virtual Reality’s Nagging Problem: It Makes Some People Sick
Facebook is going to need to find a killer app to get people to buy the Oculus Rift. But it also needs to deal with a queasy problem. View this image › Attendees play a video game wearing Oculus Rift virtual reality headsets at the Intel booth at the International Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in […]

Facebook is going to need to find a killer app to get people to buy the Oculus Rift. But it also needs to deal with a queasy problem.

Attendees play a video game wearing Oculus Rift virtual reality headsets at the Intel booth at the International Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in Las Vegas. The Associated Press

Facebook’s Oculus Rift virtual reality headset — and the VR industry in general — still have a technical problem to solve as they push to turn the technology mainstream: Using it makes some people feel sick.

In early versions of headsets like the Oculus Rift, simulation sickness — a phenomenon in which people become nauseous while playing a game on a VR headset — emerged as a surprising but not unexpected issue. Despite describing it as a “magical” experience overall, David Helgason, the CEO of gaming software company Unity, told BuzzFeed News the first version of the developer kit he used made him feel sick.

Historically, similar issues have emerged in piloting simulators and other immersive computer systems that can lead to sensory mismatches. If someone feels like they are walking around while wearing a VR headset, but their body is not actually moving, the result can be a feeling similar to motion sickness.

VR technology is certainly improving, with each new version producing a higher-quality experience. But it’s hard to tell exactly what the impact will be until the devices are in use among a large consumer base, according to some game developers and executives.

As part of a larger story about the state of VR as the industry races to widespread adoption, BuzzFeed News interviewed Dr. Nik Blevins, chief of the Division of Otology and Neurotology and an expert in vertigo at Stanford Health Care, to discuss the phenomenon.

Dr. Blevins has also researched the use of virtual reality in surgery simulation. Here’s an edited transcript of our interview.

Can you tell us a little bit about simulation sickness?

Dr. Nik Blevins: If you look at this from a balance, you look at why people get carsick, it’s really a discrepancy between all of the senses, between how much you’re moving and in what direction. There are a number of senses that give us an idea of where we are in space; one is our inner ear, two is our vision. Our eyes tell us where we move. Our inner ears give us information about linear and rotational acceleration. Then we have other senses: our touch sensation, what you feel about your skin, your joint position, the joints in your neck, your muscles that change when you move in space. Then you have to integrate all of that in your central nervous system, and you have to take the appropriate action given the cumulative info provided by those senses.

The problem is, some people much more so than others can be very intolerant of mismatches between the sensory info that comes in. For example, when people get sick in the back of a car and read, is because their inner ears are feeling every bump and curve, but your eyes and touch and muscles are experiencing the same motion sensation. So your brain is trying to make sense of these disparate sensory input, and it makes you sick. That sensory mismatch that is intolerable, some people are wired in such a way that any slight sensory mismatch provokes really horrible sickness, and some people can tolerate huge mismatches and not blink an eye.

What about in virtual reality environments?

NB: What we see in these VR environments, we’re very good at providing some very compelling sensory inputs. We’re moving in a certain environment, but we can’t match all the sensations that go along with that. If you put on VR goggles and you’re in an environment that says you’re in a roller coaster, the other senses say you’re standing in a lab. It’s the same mismatch you would get if you were reading in the back of your car, or below deck on a boat. That’s really the challenge: We don’t have a way in your VR interfaces to match all of the senses that are required to have a unified picture of an artificial environment.

Is there a way to tune down the VR experience in such a way that it doesn’t impact that sensory mismatch as much?

NB: It’s kind of a paradox as I understand it. Usually what we’re manipulating in VR environments is vision. We’re pretty good at presenting a compelling 3D moving environment. You want to make that compelling, you want to make that so real that it overcomes the fact that you’re standing in a still room. You can turn down the sense of motion in your vision, but you’re doing that at the expense of the realism of the experience of the VR environment.

I don’t think there’s a way to make that VR environment real and compelling without having a risk of having it out of phase or out of sync with your other sensory inputs. I think there’s a bit of a paradox: If you turn down the realism of the visuals you are necessarily gonna alter the realism.

What about as the technology improves?

NB: Again, some people, it’s gonna have a big impact on, some people it’s not. It’s hard to tell what your audience is. The better the virtual environment is, the less you’ll have disturbing sensory input. Having high refresh rates with good graphic quality that meets the 3D expectations of your visual system is going to help. What I’ve found in some of this, from personal experience, using immersive technology in our lab, if the parallax and the stereoscopic presentation of the environment is off, even without a lot of motion, you’ll feel disconnected with the environment. That leads you to have more risk; your brain can find discrepancies between your right and left eye. In general the better the visual fidelity, the less likely you’re gonna have bothersome input.

I think from a physiological standpoint, the way to get around it would be to provide additional sensory input from the other senses, but that’s a difficult thing to do technically.

Would the problem be resolved if an additional sense was stimulated in the experience?

NB: I don’t think we really know the answer to that; different people show such variable responses to these mismatched sensory stimuli. I see this every day when I see patients, people who have an otherwise small inner ear problem on one side that are just incapacitated by it because they can’t cope with one ear being off. We see some people who have lost an ear completely who are hardly bothered.

In some ways, situations where sensory input that’s really different than the input can have a bigger effect than input that’s just a little bit different. If it’s close and you can’t put it together, sometimes it’s worse than something that’s far off that you can ignore. Because we’re working with people that are always wired differently, it’s hard to say one is always gonna be better than the other.

You can see that in some of the simulated roller coasters or flight sims that have some inner ear stimulation associated with it — in many ways that’s something that can induce additional sickness rather than mitigate it because you’re simulating the inner ear and the eyes, but you’re not quite stimulating the ears correctly. You can’t simulate all the inputs to the inner ear; you’re substituting one sense for the other. For linear acceleration, tipping the ride or the simulator, rather than moving it in a linear way, there’s subtle differences to that which can really evoke more of a sense of dissonance in your sensory input.

Read more: http://www.buzzfeed.com/mattlynley/virtual-realitys-nagging-problem-it-makes-people-sick

10 Old-School Perfumes That Need To Make A Comeback

click photo for more information
10 Old-School Perfumes That Need To Make A Comeback
According to Fragrantica, this scent was first introduced in the 1920s and was discontinued in the late 1960s.  Evening in Paris, or Soir de Paris, includes both fruity (bergamot, apricot and peach) and floral (rose and lily of the valley) notes, with a base consisting of amber, sandalwood, musk and vanilla.  2. Chanel No. 5 […]

It Is Way More Expensive To Be My Girlfriend Than It Is To Be Me

click photo for more information
It Is Way More Expensive To Be My Girlfriend Than It Is To Be Me
Just for fun, I pretended to be my girlfriend for a month. I am now broke. My girlfriend, Jessica, is not who you’d classify as a high-maintenance person or a “pinkies-out” girl. (I mean, she’s obviously a princess and not a slob at all and I love you, girlfriend.) But she’s no cupcake. She’s an editor […]

Kidney racket: doctors meet health minister

click photo for more information
Kidney racket: doctors meet health minister
Apprehensive of an adverse impact on organ transplant programmes in the country following the arrests of doctors in the kidney racket at the L.H. Hiranandani Hospital, a delegation of medical experts Read more: http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/mumbai/news/kidney-racket-doctors-meet-health-minister/article8986518.ece?utm_source=RSS_Feed&utm_medium=RSS&utm_campaign=RSS_Syndication

These 13 Simple Tips Will Help You Fall Asleep Faster And Wake Up Rested. They’re Genius.

click photo for more information
These 13 Simple Tips Will Help You Fall Asleep Faster And Wake Up Rested. They’re Genius.
For thousands of people in the United States alone, falling asleep and staying asleep is a huge problem. You wouldn’t think that something natural could be so challenging, but the National Institutes of Health estimates that “roughly 30 percent of the general population complains of sleep disruption, and approximately 10 percent have associated symptoms of daytime functional impairment consistent with the […]

A Lot Of Women Are Shaving Their Faces. Here’s What You Need To Know.

click photo for more information
A Lot Of Women Are Shaving Their Faces. Here’s What You Need To Know.
So you want to try shaving your face, eh? Many women have long touted facial shaving, an at-home, less intense version of dermaplaning. It is the practice of using a razor to shave the peach fuzz and hair off of your face in pursuit of hair removal and smoother, exfoliated skin. Perhaps you’ve heard that Marilyn […]

An amateur’s guide to painting with light

click photo for more information
An amateur’s guide to painting with light
We live in a world where an impactful image can be just as easily made using a cell phone or a DSLR. It is, after all, the photographer and not the tool that makes for beauty. That said, knowing how Read more: http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/mumbai/entertainment/an-amateurs-guide-to-painting-with-light/article8946524.ece?utm_source=RSS_Feed&utm_medium=RSS&utm_campaign=RSS_Syndication

12 Strange Medical Conditions You Never Knew You Needed To Fear — OMG

click photo for more information
12 Strange Medical Conditions You Never Knew You Needed To Fear — OMG
It’s pretty easy these days to completely freak yourself out by researching various diseases and disorders on the internet. No matter what symptoms you look up, they all seem to point towards cancer or another fatal disease. This is exactly why I don’t take medical websites that help you self-diagnose too seriously — I worry […]

New Moms Go Through So Much, So This Woman Pointed Out Something That Needs To Stop

click photo for more information
New Moms Go Through So Much, So This Woman Pointed Out Something That Needs To Stop
When Kelly Howland went to the store with her newborn baby, she was probably expecting her tiny, adorable daughter to get a lot of attention from fellow shoppers. What she didn’t expect, however, was to be approached by another woman who was trying to sell her weight loss products when it was clear that she […]

10 Symbols In Your Dreams That You Definitely Shouldn’t Ignore

click photo for more information
10 Symbols In Your Dreams That You Definitely Shouldn’t Ignore
Do you ever wake up from a vivid dream and wonder, “What in the HELL did that mean?” Sometimes we can write off our dreams as bizarre musings of the mind. However, there are some dreams that experts say you should never ignore. From teeth falling out to dying, they may hint at deeper issues […]

Heres the 19th batch of 500 Startups companies

click photo for more information
Heres the 19th batch of 500 Startups companies
500 Startups just wrapped up its 18th batch of company launches last month which means its already looking forward to the next one. This time around, in its 19th batch, the program (no longer called an accelerator, ironically) has 44 companies, ranging from business-to-business software to beauty products. Youll find everything from software for managing […]

Amelia Earhart Could Have Died As A Castaway On A Remote Pacific Island

click photo for more information
Amelia Earhart Could Have Died As A Castaway On A Remote Pacific Island
Amelia Earhart disappeared on July 2, 1937, as she attempted to circumnavigate the globe. Her Lockheed Model 10 Electra plane seemed to have vanished into thin air somewhere over the central Pacific Ocean, and to this day, no one is quite sure what happened to her. Many assumed that a fault or pilot error caused […]

Nivea’s sunscreen-sh*tting seagull is being hailed as 2016’s stupidest ad

click photo for more information
Nivea’s sunscreen-sh*tting seagull is being hailed as 2016’s stupidest ad
Image: Nivea Faced with stubborn kids who refuse to wear sunscreen at the beach, what exasperated parent hasn’t gazed longingly at the sky, wishing that a seagull might soar overhead and heroically sh*t lotion on their insubordinate children? That’s the premise of an ad campaign that one advertising legend recently called “the most stupid thing […]

Everyone Knows These 10 Scientific Facts. The Problem Is, They’re Not Facts.

click photo for more information
Everyone Knows These 10 Scientific Facts. The Problem Is, They’re Not Facts.
You may very well love science, but do you actually know anything about it? What are its favorite movies? How many slices of pizza it will eat when in a judgement-free zone? … No? I knew you didn’t really know science. You probably believe a lot of things that aren’t true. Many people accept these […]

16 Crazy Myths That People Believe About Their Own Bodies

click photo for more information
16 Crazy Myths That People Believe About Their Own Bodies
The human body is an amazing thing. It can fight off diseases, digest food, and regulate all of your bodily functions automatically. But there are things that hundreds of people believe about the human body that aren’t true at all. In fact, you might believe in some of these myths as well. Luckily for you, […]

John Mayer gives everyone clarity by sharing his skincare secrets

click photo for more information
John Mayer gives everyone clarity by sharing his skincare secrets
Image: john mayer/snapchat John Mayer‘s beauty routine is a wonderland. On Wednesday night, the singer showed fans another side of himself by posting an unexpected tutorial detailing his night-time beauty regimen to Snapchat. “You know, a lot of people ask me, ‘John, what are some of your skincare secrets?’ the singer shared on his Snapchat […]
More