FDA’s New Blood Donation Guidelines Offer Little Clarity For Transgender People

FDA’s New Blood Donation Guidelines Offer Little Clarity For Transgender People

click photo for more information
FDA’s New Blood Donation Guidelines Offer Little Clarity For Transgender People
Doctors criticize the FDA for applying its ban on blood donations based on a person’s sex at birth, not their risky or safe behavior. View this image › montiannoowong/montiannoowong The Food and Drug Administration’s proposal to change its 30-year-old policy that bans men who have had sex with another man from donating blood for life […]

Doctors criticize the FDA for applying its ban on blood donations based on a person’s sex at birth, not their risky or safe behavior.

montiannoowong/montiannoowong

The Food and Drug Administration’s proposal to change its 30-year-old policy that bans men who have had sex with another man from donating blood for life has highlighted a problem not often discussed in connection with the so-called “gay blood ban”: the policy’s incoherent, arbitrary treatment of transgender people.

“Our policy is to designate by sex at birth,” FDA spokesperson Tara Goodin told BuzzFeed News. “That is all there is to it.”

The policy, medical experts say, creates for transgender people what is, effectively, an inverse of the blood ban applied to other people. For example, a transgender woman who only has sex with straight men is banned from donating blood. A transgender man who is gay and has sex with men, on the other hand, is allowed to donate blood.

“The existing policy is flawed at its core,” Madeline Deutsch, a medical doctor and director of clinical service at the Center of Excellence for Transgender Health at UCSF, told BuzzFeed News, “and transgender people highlight this problem.”

The policy regarding trans people is “confusing,” added Kenneth Mayer, a professor of medicine at Harvard University and the medical research director at The Fenway Institute, a research and policy center that focuses on LGBT people and HIV.

“Somebody who is a biological man who transitioned to become a transgender woman could be quite high-risk or may be very low-risk depending on who their partners are,” Mayer said. “In my mind, making a categorical statement without having any behavior data is problematic.”

This application of the rule to trans people has been the FDA’s position for some time, but BuzzFeed pressed the question for weeks after the agency announced in December that it would propose reforming the policy in 2015, limiting the ban to men who have had sex with men in the previous year. The FDA, however, calcified around the rules.

“Recent scientific data continue to indicate that transgender females are at high HIV risk,” Goodin, the FDA spokesperson told BuzzFeed News, adding, “The FDA currently recommends that male to female transgender individuals should be regarded as males for the purposes of determining donor eligibility.”

But when BuzzFeed repeatedly asked about blood donations from other demographics of transgender people — such as transgender men who were born female — Goodin said, “I ran this through several different people at the FDA, and the FDA cannot generally respond to hypothetical situations.”

Deutsch, the UCSF doctor, was astounded at that response.

“Someone at the FDA saying a transgender person is hypothetical is a real-life example of how transgender people are not calculated in when policies are made,” said Deutsch. She said that lack of awareness and accommodation in health policy causes a “cycle of bad health outcomes.”

Transgender people make up nearly 700,000 people in the United States, which is roughly the number of Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islanders, Deutsch pointed out. “If you called the FDA and said a policy has negative impact on Hawaiian Americans, they would not say that is a hypothetical. They would either already have them included in the policy or they would put their tail between their legs and think of some kind of response.”

The experts added that the incoherence of the FDA’s policy with regards to transgender people illustrated the larger problems with the policy — problems that led to criticism of the proposal to change the ban from a lifetime ban to a one-year ban.

“It is absurd to determine eligibility based on how someone identifies and who they are attracted to. It should have to do with behaviors that put someone in a high-risk category,” Deutsch said. Those risky behaviors include IV drug use, unprotected sex with multiple partners, and sex while intoxicated. She supports a policy that assesses behavior, not binary gender roles or sexual orientation, as the basis for denying blood donations.

The FDA’s Goodin would only say that where the policy is unclear, medical professionals in the field have leeway to ban potential donors. “[T]he ultimate determination of donor suitability is made by the medical director of the blood or plasma establishment,” she said. “Establishments may voluntarily elect more stringent donor deferral criteria than those required or recommended by the FDA.”

But that could mean banning all transgender people from donating blood — something that Mara Keisling, the executive director of the National Center for Transgender Equality, told BuzzFeed News is often the case.

“In practice, it has been a ban on transgender people donating blood,” Keisling said in December. “We have transgender people who have tried to donate and been told transgender people are excluded, while other people are told you qualify as a gay man, and it doesn’t matter if the person is a transgender man or a transgender woman. It’s just the usual ignorance we have to deal with.”

The FDA’s treatment of the issue is in marked contrast to the Obama administration in other areas, most notably in terms of education and workplace discrimination.

Goodin did note that “[t]he FDA encourages all stakeholders, including those concerned about transgender issues, to take the opportunity to provide comments on the draft guidance.”

The American Civil Liberties Union told BuzzFeed it intends to do just that.

“By its very nature, the current one-size-fits-all policy needlessly bars many very low-risk individuals — gay, bisexual and transgender — from being eligible to donate. Decisions on donor criteria must be based on science, and not on outdated stereotypes,” said Ian Thompson, ACLU legislative representative.

The FDA has not yet set a date for proposing the new policy.


Read more: http://www.buzzfeed.com/dominicholden/fda-clings-to-arbitrary-incoherent-rules-for-transgender-peo

Chrissy Teigen Just Did Something INCREDIBLE For This Beauty School Student

click photo for more information
Chrissy Teigen Just Did Something INCREDIBLE For This Beauty School Student
…AND GETS ALL UP IN YOUR FACEBOOK

9 Life Hacks To Help Avoid (And Get Rid Of) Acne Now And Forever

click photo for more information
9 Life Hacks To Help Avoid (And Get Rid Of) Acne Now And Forever
Theres nothing worse (well, almost nothing) than waking up to a big zit on your face. When you have acne or even when you just have a once-in-a-while breakout, it can make you feel self-conscious and uncomfortable. Sometimes the best way to deal with a breakout is to prevent it from happening initially. There are […]

She Took Her Daughter In For A Free Eye Exam And It Ended Up Saving Her Life

click photo for more information
She Took Her Daughter In For A Free Eye Exam And It Ended Up Saving Her Life
Most optometrists and eye care clinics offer free eye exams for new patients. In most cases, this is done simply to add new patients to the roster in hopes that the exams will result in returning customers. One pre-teen in New Zealand, however, walked into an eye care clinic looking for a new pair of […]

These 14 Colorful Bodies Of Water Look Too Cool To Be Real, But They Are

click photo for more information
These 14 Colorful Bodies Of Water Look Too Cool To Be Real, But They Are
googletag.cmd.push(function() { googletag.display(‘VN_PG_DTBT_ATF’); }); Nature is pretty incredible, isn’t it? Sometimes, we get so caught up in our daily lives that we forget that there’s a whole world out there to explore. Although every city, town, and country has its fair share of man-made tourist attractions, natural landmarks really pique my interest. Maybe I just […]

17 Shocking Confessions From Gun Owners That’ll Really Make You Think

click photo for more information
17 Shocking Confessions From Gun Owners That’ll Really Make You Think
The second amendment of the U.S. Constitution grants Americans the right to bear arms, but in the wake of recent events, the war over gun control has become a hot-button issue. With factors such as media attention and political pressures adding fuel to the fire, the issue of gun control has unfortunately divided the nation. […]

Woman’s Pic Before-And-After Makeup Gets Real About Flaws Social Media Hides

click photo for more information
Woman’s Pic Before-And-After Makeup Gets Real About Flaws Social Media Hides
Beck Lomas has a lot going for her. The 22-year-old Australian woman posts Instagrams to nearly 200,000 followers, inspiring them with her dedication to fitness and a brilliant smile. But, as youve probably realized by now, its easy to hide your flaws behind a filter. A few weeks ago, Lomas got real with her fans, […]

Valeant Turns From Buyer to Seller as Debt Repayments Loom

click photo for more information
Valeant Turns From Buyer to Seller as Debt Repayments Loom
Over the last six years, Valeant Pharmaceuticals International Inc. piled up a mountain of debt building its business through more than 50 acquisitions. It now may have to sell some of those very same assets to help pay off almost $5 billion that will come due by or during 2018. If that sounded bad enough, […]

‘Largest-ever’ Silicon Valley eviction to displace hundreds of tenants

click photo for more information
‘Largest-ever’ Silicon Valley eviction to displace hundreds of tenants
Demolition of 216-unit complex is the latest example of rising income inequality in a region home to many of the worlds wealthiest technology companies Iris Milano could hardly sleep after she got the news that her family would be kicked out of their two-bedroom apartment in San Jose. Youre always thinking and worrying. Its something […]

Chrissy Teigen Becomes This Aspiring Esthetician’s Fairy Godmother!

click photo for more information
Chrissy Teigen Becomes This Aspiring Esthetician’s Fairy Godmother!
What a super story! Mercedes Edney, who owns her own skincare company, had only received about $300 with her crowd-sourcing campaign to raise money so she could attend esthetician school in Charlotte, North Carolina. That’s when Chrissy stepped up and paid the remaining $5,600 so that Mercedes could fulfill her dreams! After being thanked, Chrissy […]

This School District Is Warning Parents About An Outbreak Of Leprosy…Oops

click photo for more information
This School District Is Warning Parents About An Outbreak Of Leprosy…Oops
When someone says leprosy, what’s is your gut reaction to the word? For centuries, those with leprosy have been ostracized and vilified by societies all over the world. This reaction comes from the perception that leprosy is a highly contagious and permanent condition. Luckily, leprosy is relatively easy to treat in the West. Still, you […]

Are all tampons toxic? No one seems to have the answer

click photo for more information
Are all tampons toxic? No one seems to have the answer
Despite a profusion of non-toxic menstrual products, little research has been conducted to determine whether tampons actually pose a health risk There are more than seven manufacturers of organic cotton tampons and four tampon subscription services in the US, but a new venture seeks to combine the two. Cora is a Pennsylvania-based, angel investor-backed company […]

Ulta Investors Are Just Confused

click photo for more information
Ulta Investors Are Just Confused
This summer's steep selloff in shares of Ulta Beauty Inc. shows that investors still don't understand the beauty-supply chain.  It was just last month that Ulta closed at an all-time high of $313.73 a share, but it didn't stay up there for long. The stock tumbled 18 percent in the short time since then, erasing nearly […]

Valeant Hires Morgan Stanley to Sell Dermatology Assets

click photo for more information
Valeant Hires Morgan Stanley to Sell Dermatology Assets
Valeant Pharmaceuticals International Inc. is working with advisers at Morgan Stanley as it weighs the sale of dermatology units Obagi Medical Products and Solta Medical to raise cash to reduce debt, according to people familiar with the matter. The two businesses could fetch as much as $500 million and attract interest from other pharmaceutical companies, the […]

Revlon Seeks to Revive Cosmetics Clout With Elizabeth Arden Deal

click photo for more information
Revlon Seeks to Revive Cosmetics Clout With Elizabeth Arden Deal
Revlon Inc. will acquire Elizabeth Arden Inc. for about $419 million, a wager that uniting two aging cosmetics giants can reinvigorate both companies brands. The $14-a-share deal values Elizabeth Arden at about $870 million when debt is included, New York-based Revlon said on Thursday. The cash transaction represents a 50 percent premium over Elizabeth Ardens […]

Are skin serums miracle workers or the purest distillation of beauty industry BS?

click photo for more information
Are skin serums miracle workers or the purest distillation of beauty industry BS?
The potent and pricey face supplements became a $4.1m market in 2015, but tend to be full of sketchy science: a cocktail of vague claims in pretty packaging Cocaine used to be Gods way of telling you that you have too much money. Now its SoulCycle and skin serums. Over the last decade wellness has […]
More